The list of Incumbents of St Mary's Gate Helmsley stretches back to 1351. With the exception of 142 years from 1547 the list is complete.

Vicars of St Mary’s Church, Gate Helmsley

1351  John de Howgate               1800  Joseph Ellis

1375  Charles de Esyngwold          1811  John Wilkinson

1376  Peter de Bambury              1846  Bemnjimin E Metcalfe

1377  William de Lepyngton          1851  John Farrow

1389  Thomas de Buxton              1872  Robert Taylor

1391  Walter de Lepyngton           1875  George Alexander England

1392  William de Lathome            1882  Stewart B Casey

1413  William Walton                1895  Francis Bartell Proctor

1421  Robert Dyghton                1913  Arthur Lionel Whitaker

1421  Robert Curter                 1924  Benjamin W Wood

1422  John Darell                   1929 – 30 Inter-regnum

1423  Walter Catton                 1930  Harry Henry Officer

1423  Thomas Bellamy                1939  Reginald Trevor Hughes

1472  Robert Beverley               1950  Richard Rae Beckitt

1484  Robert Hobson                 1960  W Ronald George

1490  John Ronde                    1981  Bernard A Brownbridge

1507  Thomas Barre                  1987  Jeremy Valentine

1539  Robert Sharpe                 2008 – Inter-regnum

1541  Robert Jackson                2009  Ivan Howitt

1547  Christopher Richardson        2013 - Inter-regnum

Records lost for 142 years                    2014    Chris Wingfield

1689  John Waite

1725  John Bradley

1774  John Cantley